lummi island wine tasting june 30 ’23
Open Friday, June 30, from 4-6pm
Good News #1… Our plans to be away this weekend just changed to avoid a forecasted heat wave, so we WILL BE OPEN Friday, June 30 from 4-6pm for wine tasting and sales!
Good News #2… Beginning July 7, we will be expanding our summer hours to be open both Fridays and Saturdays from 4-6pm!

Blue sky, blue water
-view from island side ferry dock
Friday Bread Pickup This Week

Polenta Levain –– Also made with a levain, aka sourdough, from a starter fed and built up over several days, then mixed with bread flour and polenta in the final dough mix. This bread is a nice rustic loaf with great corn flavor. – $5/loaf
and pastry this week…
Pain aux Raisin – made with the same laminated dough as croissants. The dough is rolled out, spread with pastry cream and sprinkled with a mix of golden raisins and dried cranberries that have been soaked in sugar syrup. Rolled up and sliced before baking. These
To get on the bread order list, click the “Contact Us” link above and fill out the form. Each week’s bread menu is sent to the list each Sunday, for ordering by Tuesday, for pickup on Friday. Simple, right..? If you will be visiting the island and would like to order bread for your visit, at least a week’s notice is recommended for pickup the following Friday.
Wine of the Week: Lambert de Seyssal Petit Royal France $22
The village of Seyssel, in Savoie in the French Alps, has a history of viticulture dating back centuries, having built a reputation for floral-scented charmers from the local grapes, Molette and Altesse. Produced in the méthode traditionnelle and aged for two years sur latte, the Petit Royal is unequaled in the world of sparkling wine. Nose of alpine flowers, dried fruit, wildflower honey, and a toasty, yeasty note give this the wine an utterly delightful aromatic richness and complexity. Serve it with various salty toasts to kick off your next dinner party, or pop one open to liven up a night at home with a big bowl of mac and cheese. Versatile!
Lambert de Seyssal Royal Seyssal France $22
Great sparkling wine from the Savoie region; 50% Altesse, 50% Molette from clay/limestone soils. Stacked sur latte for 3-4 years, yielding complex aromas, fine perlage (bubbles), and crisp acidity. Yummy stuff!
This week’s wine tasting
Lambert de Seyssal Royal Seyssal France $22
Great sparkling wine from the Savoie region; 50% Altesse, 50% Molette from clay/limestone soils. Stacked sur latte for 3-4 years, yielding complex aromas, fine perlage (bubbles), and crisp acidity. Yummy stuff!
Natura Rose ’21 Chile $12
Cold-soaked before pressing and cold-fermented on the skins to develop rich and nuanced aromas and flavors of grassy lime, tropical fruits, and lychee, with a crisp, lingering finish.
Angeline Cabernet Sauvignon ’20 California $14
Deep garnet hue with aromas of lush cherry, cassis, and plum lead to rich cherry and plum flavors and lingering notes of vanilla and creamy oak…seriously over-delivers for its modest price tag.
Economics of the Heart: Crossing Lines vs. Lines Crossing, pt 2

courtesy www.dogtopia.com
It has been an intense week in our local ferry liaison world. At the time of last week’s post about all of this, tensions and temperatures were rising quickly, and dialogue was deeply stressed and reactive between the two opposing viewpoints in the “conflict.”
On Tuesday this week, the Chair of the Ferry Advisory Committee (I am a member) announced a “special meeting” for today with the “clearly hidden” intention of subverting decisions that had been made both at our last meeting on June 14 and the subsequent Council meeting on June 20 to postpone Council consideration of a radical ferry rate ordinance change submitted by Public Works (like, since when do the regulatees get to rewrite the regulations??). The clear intent of the special meeting was to override the decisions previously made and create a back door through which to remove ALL the guardrails on the kinds and magnitudes of costs PW could pass off as “ordinary maintenance” in computing our fare burden. (I am not making this up).
The short version of a very long and complicated story is that a volunteer citizens’ group (including two very good lawyers and not affiliated with Lifac) worked very hard to identify several ways in which the meeting violated the WA Open Meetings Act. As a result, around mid-day today the meeting was officially cancelled– a HUGE victory for the grass roots effort and a welcome sense of relief after a long and difficult week. For the moment, anyway.
Some residents are angry at the Lifac Chair in particular for putting us all through this trauma. And that is certainly fair to some degree. But it is also true that these experiences reveal how much the entire system is broken and dysfunctional. The Ferry Committee has essentially ignored since its inception nearly all of its codified responsibilities (see below), and instead has focused most of its attention on deferring to Public Works. Presently, about 4.5 of the 7 Lifac members seem to believe that their primary responsibility is to give PW everything it asks for, a consistent majority. So while there is a bit of breathing room, let’s take a moment to speculate how in the world we got here, and if and how the system might be fixed.
The founding statute of the Lummi Island Ferry Advisory Committee (WCC Chapter 2.145), defines its charge as to “provide review and recommendations to the Whatcom County Council and Executive on issues that affect the ongoing operations and infrastructure of ferry service to Lummi Island…and also provide a forum for those who depend upon Lummi Island ferry service to voice their ideas and concerns about the ferry service.”
The specific charge of the committee is to advise the county council or the county executive on the following functions:
A. Review and provide recommendations on proposed changes to ferry operations and fares;
B. Review at least annually ferry revenue and expenditures, ferry fund balance, and actual versus targeted fare return;
C. Assist the county in collecting information from ferry riders on actual and desired ferry services, concerns, and ideas for improved service;
D. Analyze and develop recommendations to continue and improve the cost effective operation of ferry service to Lummi Island;
E. Research, review, and make recommendations regarding ferry replacement, long-term planning, parking, transportation to and from ferry docks, alternative docking locations, alternative funding sources, and other major capital and operational issues regarding ferry service to Lummi Island. (Ord. 2012-005 Exh. A).
Your attention is invited in particular to the fact that the ordinance is silent about any liaison between Lifac and Public Works, which operates and maintains the ferry and related infrastructure.
On the face it is a bit hard to imagine why there might be much cause for policy disagreement. But it turns out that over the dozen or so years the committee has existed, the necessity of some ongoing liaison with Public Works, which operates and maintains ferry operations and infrastructure, seems to have morphed Lifac into a sort of satellite department of Public Works. Each new member picks up the vibe and many start to believe that their real job is to make sure Public Works gets whatever it asks for. And in the meantime the responsibilities and tasks listed above receive minimal attention or are completely ignored.
To be clear: there is now an established, majority “culture of obeisance” to Public Works on Lifac that prevents it from attending to its responsibilities to serve the needs and interests of ferry users, who include not just island residents, but the entire flow of commerce between island and mainland. In its present configuration Lifac is creating problems faster than it is helpng to solve any. There is no simple fix for that, but it falls to the Council to address the present ongoing dysfunction. In, you know, mho.
lummi island wine tasting june 23, ’23
Hours through June: Fridays from 4-6pm
Good News #1… We will be open as usual this Friday, June 23, from 4-6pm for wine tasting and sales!
Not-So-Good News… Due to family obligations, the wine shop will be closed next Friday June 30;
Good News #2… Beginning July 7, we will be expanding our summer hours to be open both Fridays and Saturdays from 4-6pm!
Friday Bread Pickup This Week

Spelt Levain – – Spelt is an ancient grain that is a wheat. It has a nutty, slightly sweet flavor and has gluten but it isn’t as strong as the gluten in modern wheat. This bread is made with a culture that is used to create a levain before the final dough is mixed with traditional bread flour, spelt flour, fresh milled whole spelt and fresh milled whole rye. – $5/loaf.
and pastry this week…
Brioche Tarts au Sucre (Brioche sugar tarts)– A rich brioche dough full of eggs and butter, rolled into a round tart and topped with more eggs, cream, butter and sugar. While these are good on their own, they are a perfect substitute for shortcake biscuits for all of the fresh fruit of the season.- 2/$5
To get on the bread order list, click the “Contact Us” link above and fill out the form. Each week’s bread menu is sent to the list each Sunday, for ordering by Tuesday, for pickup on Friday. Simple, right..? If you will be visiting the island and would like to order bread for your visit, at least a week’s notice is recommended for pickup the following Friday.
Wine of the Week: Seven Hills Walla Walla Cabernet ’20 WA $32

Seven Hills pioneered the planting of primary Bordeaux varietals merlot and cabernet sauvignon in the area, demonstrating that the soil and climate of the area were ideally suited for vineyards in general and these varietals in particular. The winery has forged long-standing relationships with many of the most prestigious vineyards in the region, including Ciel du Cheval and Klipsun at Red Mountain and McClellan and Summit View in Walla Walla. The wines have an established reputation for a quiet, reliable quality. You will like it!
Tasting notes: Aromas of red cherries, black raspberry, and black tea, with hints of fresh herbs, cedar box, and earth; flavors of cherry, raspberry, dark chocolate, baking spice, and vanilla; medium bodied with plush texture, firm tannins, and balanced acidity.
This week’s wine tasting
Attems Collio Sauvignon Blanc ’19 Italy $17
Straw yellow with green highlights and characteristic bouquet of boxwood, tomato leaves and grapefruit, a bright, crisp palate of blossoms and lime, and a long, bright finish.
Monte Tondo Veneto Corvina ’20 Italy $12
Organically farmed; bright nose of fresh cherries and black pepper; fresh, light, and lively palate of cherry, dark chocolate and spice, with supple, well-integrated tannins and a smooth, seductive, slightly spicy finish.
Seven Hills Walla Walla Cabernet ’20 WA $32
Aromas of red cherries, black raspberry, and black tea, with hints of fresh herbs, cedar box, and earth; flavors of cherry, raspberry, dark chocolate, baking spice, and vanilla; medium bodied with plush texture, firm tannins, and balanced acidity
Economics of the Heart: Crossing Lines vs. Line Crossing
In economics “optimality” is “the place where the lines cross,” where no alternative resource allocation can produce higher net benefits. “Where the lines cross” implies the best available balance between benefits and costs; it’s what we aim for, as at Q in the image, the project size where the difference between total benefits (TSB) and total costs (TSC) is the greatest.
It is quite the opposite of “crossing the line,” which implies throwing out all the rules in in service to political expediency. Boo-hiss, huh?
Events of the past couple of months have brought this distinction into sharp political relief here on the island.
For the past six months, our community has been engaged in a pitched battle with County Public Works about ferry economics. In mid-December Public Works proposed a major ferry fare increase to be reviewed by the Lummi Island Ferry Advisory Committee (LIFAC, of which I am a member) at its January meeting, with an expectation that it would be forwarded to the County Council and passed into law a couple of weeks later, with little discussion or scrutiny. However, island residents proposed a convincing counter-proposal which was passed on to the CC and postponed action on the fare increase.
By April PW had introduced a radical revision of the entire ordinance governing ferry operations (WCC 10.34) and financing (current / proposed), which would remove all guard rails limiting the expenses that could be charged against fares. These guard rails are regulated not only by County ordinance but also by numerous state and federal statutes as well as terms of our annual contract with WSDOT governing annual subsidies from State fuel tax revenues.
The pro-PW majority on Lifac has tried various ways to pass it without discussion. You can see some of that in this video, which begins with considerable public input. You can watch the video and make up your own mind how responsive Lifac was to the public. (Public comments begin at 22:25; the meeting gets interesting at 1:21:00; and starts whimpering to a non-decision over the last 10 minutes or so with a series of interruptions. The main takeaway is that the entire front table completely believed everything PW was asserting despite mounting evidence to the contrary.
Subsequent public outcry from the island community delayed the process long enough to demonstrate that a) PW has made numerous major accounting errors in their calculations ; b) there is actually a $1M surplus in the ferry fund, not a deficit; and c) PW has already passed such expenses onto the fare burden in violation of governing County ordinance which is still in effect.
The June meeting passed a request to the Council to make three important changes to the ordinance, including postponing discussion of the new ordinance till July. Due to extensive public pressure, including a petition with over 700 signatures, and a number of great presentations by members of the public, the delay was granted. That’s good news.
Meanwhile, evidence is mounting of some grievous ethical violations on the part of some of some players in this parochial little saga going a bit too far to get their way, but still a few more details to confirm on that, no need to hurry.
lummi island wine tasting june 16 ’23
Hours through June: Fridays from 4-6pm
wild roses at the Legoe Bay slough
Friday Bread Pickup This Week

Barley & Rye w/ Pumpkin Seeds – Made with a levain that is fermented overnight before the final dough is mixed with a nice mix of bread flour and fresh milled rye, barley and whole wheat flours. Some buttermilk makes for a tender crumb, honey for sweetness and toasted pumpkin seedsfor flavor and texture. – $5/loaf.
and pastry this week…
Rum Raisin Brioche: A delicious brioche dough full of eggs, butter and sugar. Filled with golden raisins and chunks of almond paste and (wait there’s more!) topped with a chocolate glaze before baking!- 2/$5
To get on the bread order list, click the “Contact Us” link above and fill out the form. Each week’s bread menu is sent to the list each Sunday, for ordering by Tuesday, for pickup on Friday. Simple, right..? If you will be visiting the island and would like to order bread for your visit, at least a week’s notice is recommended for pickup the following Friday.
Wine of the Week: Clos Sainte Magdeleine ’21 France $34

courtesy https://shop.kermitlynch.com
Cassis is a stunning piece of geography, set lovingly along the Mediterranean coast between Marseilles and Toulon. The carefully groomed vineyards at Clos Sainte Magdeleine sit on coastal bluffs in the heart of the Parc National des Calanques. The softly beautiful setting is a perfectly integrated blend of the area’s natural beauty and the care with which development has incorporated and even enhanced it in some ways. Steep limestone slopes and clear blue-green waters, delicate scents of garrigue and the soft Mediterranean air round out the charm that makes every wine taste even better.
We visited Clos Sainte Magdeleine several years ago, and fell in love with this lovely, richly textured white wine, and it is a great pleasure to have found a source for it and to have it on the tasting list for this weekend. The blend is 40% Marsanne, 30% Ugni blanc, 25% Clairette, and 5% Bourboulenc.
Vineyards have been cultivated here for some 2,500 years. The chalky soil, the sun, and the salt air make a perfect habitat for this unique and delicious blend of Rhone region white varietals. Come by and taste it!
This week’s wine tasting
Clos St. Magdeleine Cassis Blanc ’21 France $34
40% Marsanne, 30% Ugni blanc, 25% Clairette, and 5% Bourboulenc; Rich aromas with salty traces of garrigue and peaches; full and fleshy on the palate with a savory minerality, a cleansing, salty-stony flavor and a honeyed, dry finish. Unique and delicious!
St. Cosme Crozes-Hermitage ’20 France $18
Granite slopes give nice structure and complexity, with aromas and flavors of black fruits, smoked bacon, black peppercorn, and incense.
Marques de Caceres Rioja Red Blend Organica ’21 Spain $18
75% Tempranillo, 25% Graciano; we all loved this wine when Judy poured samples of it three weeks ago, and found it a bit disappointing when we poured it at our tasting. So third time is the charm, right? How do we really feel about it?!
Economics of the Heart: A Moment of Traction…?
courtesy https://www.redarcelectronics.co.nz
Six months ago the County Public Works Dept. that runs our ferry (our only way to the mainland, about a mile away), announced that ferry financing was suddenly found to be on the brink of disaster and would require a substantial fare increase as soon as possible to avoid financial calamity. The announcement carried a tense urgency for immediate action by the Ferry Advisory Committee ( I am a member) and the County Council to get their fare increase request reviewed, discussed, and passed within barely a month…precious little time to review the numbers and the arguments.
For a whole bunch of reasons, for a few of us that story did not seem to meet the available facts, and we started asking questions. Over the next few months, it became increasingly clear that neither the numbers nor the offered rationales could stand up to closer scrutiny. Very slowly more and more residents became concerned and interested, dug into the data, and discovered more and more indefensible errors in the proposal. Each month brought a new battle for more time for review from the public, and to move faster with the fare increase for PW.
Public resistance led to a new, distracting proposal by the County Ferry Department to, under the auspices of “clarifying ambiguities,” completely rewrite the County Ordinance that governs ferry operations to remove existing, carefully crafted limits on what expenses can be charged to fare revenues. Meanwhile, further digging by Islanders continued to uncover even more accounting errors, assertions, and outright misrepresentations going back some fifteen years that have turned the forecasted shortfall into a $2 million surplus. And while it was good news when the fare increase proposal was finally withdrawn, at least temporarily, the Ferry Dept then shifted its focus to Plan B– gutting the guiding County ordinance of the every constraint that limits the kinds of expenses that can be charged against fare box revenue.
Under the existing statute, only “regular and routine maintenance” can be charged to fare revenues. The proposed PW rule changes remove that constraint completely, opening a very wide door to allow charging “anything that we can possibly classify as maintenance” as an ordinary operating expense.
This direction is clearly demonstrated by this document I recently put together from ten years of ferry maintenance expenditures. It is clear from the charts that for most of those years, it was rare to find any individual expenses more than about $25,000. However, in more recent years the graphs show a growing “mission creep” that reaches a crescendo in 2022 and already in 2023, with individual “repairs” some ten to twenty times higher than any others in ferry accounting history.
Last night a barrage of well-spoken public comments at our monthly LIFAC meeting, (watch video) along with a petition with nearly 600 signatures (from an early summer population of maybe 1200) requesting the Council to delay any action on the proposed ordinance changes) was approved by 5 to 1 majority, a significant accomplishment. The Council, in turn, meets next week to decide on that, and we are encouraging every interested Islander to attend the meeting to lobby against the ordinance change proposal. We are hoping the Council will heed the LIFAC resolution and postpone further discussion for at least another month.
Stay tuned. It appears to be increasingly true that “just because we’re paranoid doesn’t mean they’re not out to get us!”
lummi island wine tasting june 9 ’23
Hours through June : Fridays from 4-6pm.
Can you find the wild rose Dipper…?
Friday Bread Pickup This Week
Buckwheat Rye – –A levain is made the night before final mixing of the dough using a sourdough starter. This allows the fermentation process to start and the gluten to start developing. The final dough is made with the levain, bread flour and fresh milled whole wheat and then loaded up with dried cherries and toasted pecans. A nice rustic loaf that goes well with meats and cheese – – $5/loaf
Whole Grain Spelt Sweet Levain – – Similar to a bread I sampled in Latvia it is made with a levain, also known as sourdough, freshly milled whole wheat and whole spelt before mixing with bread flour as well as a nice combination of dried apricots, golden raisins, slivered almonds and both sunflower and flax seeds. Chock full of flavor!– $5/loaf.
and pastry this week…
Kouign Aman with Cream Cheese filling – Made with the same traditional laminated french pastry used for croissants. Has both a little levain for the sourdough flavor as well as some pre-fermented dough to help build strength. When rolling out however, instead of using flour to prevent sticking, sugar is used. The dough is cut into squares, placed in cupcake tins then filled with a cream cheese filling…sort of “ a cheese Danish and a Croissant walk into a bar…”– 2/$5
To get on the bread order list, click the “Contact Us” link above and fill out the form. Each week’s bread menu is sent to the list each Sunday, for ordering by Tuesday, for pickup on Friday. Simple, right..? If you will be visiting the island and would like to order bread for your visit, at least a week’s notice is recommended for pickup the following Friday.
Wine of the Week: la Roque Pic St. Loup Rouge ’18 France $19
The “Pic” in the small French wine region of Pic St. Loup is a 640-meter (2000 ft.) “Tooth” of granite that dominates the view for miles in every direction– powerful, beautiful, vaguely remote, and iconic. It looms over a collection of very special, well-drained, limestone-rich vineyards. About an hour north of Montpellier on the Mediterranean coast to the south, it features hot days, but is also far enough north to have Atlantic-influenced cool nights that induce slow, full ripening.
The wines from Pic St. Loup must be predominantly syrah, grenache, and mourvedre (as in nearby Southern Rhone) and fairly consistently have a certain gravitas. The vines must be at least six years old (not the usual three) before considered mature enough for making red wines, but are perfect for making excellent rosé! Vineyards are scattered among rugged terrain that slopes up from the Mediterranean. Atlantic influences make the local climate cooler and wetter than elsewhere in Languedoc.
Wines from this little region typically share an earthy complexity accented by spicy, herbal aromas and flavors of the wild aromatic herbs that flourish in the area, commonly known as “garrigue.” Pic St. Loup reds typically show bold, spicy, and earthy complexity, deeper color and depth of flavor, and more elegance and refinement than wines from the hotter Languedoc plains to the south.
Economics of the Heart: Showdown at the Ferry Corral
Six months ago our November meeting of the Lummi Island Ferry Advisory Committee (LIFAC) was the annual end of year budget meeting held at the Public Works building in Bellingham. At that time we were presented with a bunch of tables and a graph that purported to show that fare revenue had fallen precipitously during COVID and that fares needed to be raised significantly and Immediately to avoid a fiscal catastrophe. Their actual proposal became available in December, and was being fast-tracked to be voted on, with little discussion, by the County Council at their January meeting, barely a month away.
Over the next several months a group of concerned islanders discovered numerous key errors in the County’s calculations and interpretations of guiding statutes. One by one the assertions made by PW have been debunked by demonstrating clearly that:
- A big chunk of the “deficit” was because PW chose not to charge any fares at all during the first several months of Covid;
- For many years PW failed to allocate correctly the two annual State subsidies provided by WSDOT to the four County ferry systems (Pierce, Skagit, Whatcom, Wahkiakum), erroneously allocating them to the County Road Fund for other uses, and illegally increasing the annual fare box burden for over a decade.
- PW recently charged the ferry fund $400.000 to replace the many rotten pilings in failing landing dolphins (the piling assemblies at foot of blue structures in photo), violating the requirement in the County statute that only “regular and ordinary repairs” could be charged to fare box proceeds. At present, with these corrections in place, the fare box has a surplus of around $2 million.
One result of this public pressure and fact-checking was the withdrawal of the proposed fare increase. For now, anyway.
However, PW has also thrown together a proposal for drastic changes to that carefully written 2011 County ordinance governing ferry operations and accounting. Suffice it to say that in the interests of “clarifying ambiguity,” the proposal seeks to remove all the guardrails that were carefully built into the statute in 2011 specifically to minimize operating cost variation from year to year.
Some have suggested that all of this turmoil about fares can be traced directly to the growing financial burden on the County of keeping our 60 yr-old Whatcom Chief plying the short mile between Lummi Island and Gooseberry Pt. thirty-some round trips a day. On that point the example of the dolphin repairs is instructive. Since the County has obtained funding for a new vessel, the only reason to “repair” it under these circumstances is to extend its life a few more years, and that could get very expensive, as the dolphin case shows.
The whole point of the existing split of ferry costs between fare revenues and general County taxation is that the ferry is an integral part of the County Road system. People travel to Lummi Island just as they travel to and from rural communities all over the State, to work, deliver, tour, and spend and earn money in our overlapping regional economy. Islanders do almost all their shopping on the mainland, and pay all the same taxes as mainland residents in addition to our fares. We pay our fair share for County-wide infrastructure. This entire controversy is about fairness.
You can look over several versions of the ordinance (links below) to get a sense of the differences, especially with regard to setting boundaries and responsibilities. If you can, plan to attend the next LIFAC meeting at the Grange (or on Zoom) at 6pm next Wednesday, and let your voice be heard. At present a LIFAC majority tips strongly in favor of anything PW wants, so your participation matters.
see PW proposed ferry ordinance
see LI working group proposed ferry ordinance
This week’s wine tasting
Pascual Toso Chardonnay ’16 Argentina $14
Aromas of ripe green apple, pineapple and mango; full, fresh palate with bright acidity, finishing with a slight toasty hint on a smooth, lingering finish.
Chateau la Roque Rouge ’18 France $19
65% Grenache, 25% Syrah, 10% Mourvèdre. A lithe and expressive red, with fine balance and well-structured flavors of dried cherry, plum, and boysenberry, featuring hints of tarragon and cream on the finish.
Eola Hills ‘Patriot Red’ Oregon $22
Zinfandel, Sangiovese, Merlot, & Pinot Noir from Oregon, Washington, & California. Intense aromas of fruitiness lead to a soft, smooth palate with flavors of red berry jam. All you need to know is it’s pretty tasty!





2072 Granger Way